The Church Intrusion
The Mystery of The Invisible DogThe church serves first as a burglar’s hiding place and later as a setting where a genuine criminal threat becomes entangled with ghost stories.
increasing
Bearing strength in each event
decreasing
A Search Begins

A Search Begins
Police at the church
After a masked man flees through the courtyard, police search St Jude’s Church. Earl insists that no one entered while he was present.
A weak witness
Earl’s deafness makes his certainty unreliable. The church’s apparent security becomes a blind spot the burglar can exploit.
The False Statue

The False Statue
Disguise in plain sight
Jupiter Jones later infers that the burglar borrowed the appearance of a saint by wearing a cape and mitre. A human impostor could stand among statues while officers searched nearby.
A dangerous concealment
The disguise buys time but leaves the criminal trapped with Earl’s return. The plan depends on darkness, confusion, and the caretaker’s limited hearing.
Earl Is Struck

Earl Is Struck
Violence in the church
Earl is found hurt in the choir loft after returning to the building. The burglar may have struck him to prevent discovery of the false statue or hidden sculpture.
Stakes increase
Earl’s injury shows that the theft is not harmless. The young investigators now face a criminal willing to attack people who interfere.
Jupiter Locked Inside

Jupiter Locked Inside
A candle-bearing figure
Jupiter Jones enters St Jude’s Church after seeing a light and encounters a pale figure dressed like a priest. A second person shoves him and locks the door.
Two intruders suspected
Jupiter concludes that the candle-bearer and his attacker could not be the same person. The case gains a new layer beyond the original burglary.
The Phantom Remains

The Phantom Remains
A rational account
Jupiter Jones considers whether the priestly figure was Sonny Elmquist, either wandering in sleep or physically present in disguise. Each possibility leaves a difficulty.
Unresolved possibility
The boys cannot prove that a ghost exists, but they cannot close every gap in the human explanations. The church remains the story’s final uncertainty.
The night of the burglary
During the first police search
Late on the night of the burglary
Around midnight on the second night
During the later reconstruction of the case